The Tunnels of Penn Station: What Was, Is, and Could Be

Ask anyone who has run from Penn Station to Herald Square in a sideways rainstorm and they'll say the same thing: There has to be a better way. Funny thing is, there used to be. For more than 60 years you could walk from Seventh Avenue to Sixth without seeing the sky once.

Then the city sealed it off. What's happened underground since then tells you a lot about where this neighborhood is headed.

The Tunnels That Were

The best known is the Gimbels Passageway. It was an 800-foot corridor under 33rd Street that opened in 1920 and closed in 1986 because of crime and disrepair. You got in at Seventh Avenue and 33rd Street, next to the uptown 1 train platform. From there you could walk all the way to the Herald Square subways, the Hudson Tubes (today's PATH), and right into the basement of Gimbels, which was Macy's biggest rival back then. When Gimbels closed in 1986, the passageway closed with it.

It wasn't the only one. Another walkway ran under Sixth Avenue from 35th to 40th Streets, connecting the Herald Square station to the 42nd Street–Bryant Park stop. It opened in the early 1940s and closed in 1991 after a horrific sexual assault. Put the two together and you could walk from Penn Station to Bryant Park without going outside.

Then there's the odd stuff. The New Yorker Hotel on Eighth Avenue had its own underground tunnel to Penn Station, and it's long closed. A 2010 Vornado planning map marks an "11 Penn Passageway" off Seventh Avenue as closed as well. During the recent renovations, workers even uncovered Guastavino vaulted ceilings in what Amtrak confirmed was the former 32nd Street connection from the downtown 7th Avenue subway into Penn Station.

These tunnels all closed for the same reasons. After the budget cuts of the 1970s, it got hard to keep these tunnels safe and clean. Long, empty corridors with nobody watching them don't survive tough decades in New York.

The Tunnels That Are

The good news is that the last decade has been the biggest stretch of underground improvements Penn Station has seen since it moved below Madison Square Garden.

It started on the west side. In June 2017, the West End Concourse opened under the old Farley Post Office across Eighth Avenue. It gave riders a new way to reach 17 of the 21 tracks at Penn, with new entrances at the 31st and 33rd Street corners of Eighth Avenue. It's also the tunnel under Eighth Avenue that ties everything together. The western end of the 33rd Street concourse ramps down a few feet to meet the subway mezzanine and the A/C/E, then ramps back up to connect with the West End Concourse and Moynihan.

Then came the big one. Moynihan Train Hall opened on January 1, 2021. It's a $1.6 billion hall designed by Skidmore, Owings & Merrill, built inside the Farley Building's former mail sorting room, with a soaring skylight made of four catenary vaults. Getting it built took 28 years of stops and starts, at least 13 different designs, and five New York governors. If you haven't walked through it yet, go. It's the first part of Penn Station in over half a century that actually feels like a train station.

The east side got its turn too. The East End Gateway, the glass entrance at Seventh Avenue and 33rd Street, opened in December 2020. Behind it, the Long Island Rail Road concourse was rebuilt from the inside out. The corridor nearly doubled in width, from 30 to 57 feet, and the ceilings were raised to 18 feet. That meant getting rid of the infamous "head knockers," low-hanging beams that hung just 6 feet 8 inches off the floor. The whole job cost about $559 million and reached substantial completion in March 2023. It matters, too. More than half of Penn Station's 600,000 daily users pass through that concourse.

Finally, in November 2023, Amtrak and Vornado reopened the busiest entrance in the station, at Seventh Avenue and 32nd Street. It's now 50 percent wider, lets natural light into the concourse, and is fully accessible.

So here's where things stand. You can head underground at Seventh Avenue and stay inside all the way west past Eighth Avenue to Moynihan, which runs to Ninth. Going east toward Herald Square is a different story. Once you hit Seventh Avenue, you're back on the sidewalk.

The Tunnels That Could Be

This is where it gets interesting, and a little messy.

The federal government took control of the Penn Station rebuild from the state in 2025. In June 2026, Amtrak and Penn Transformation Partners released the first renderings. The redesign is projected to cost roughly $8 billion, construction is targeted to begin before the end of 2027, and the work would roll out in phases over about six years while the station stays open. Madison Square Garden stays put.

The headline for tunnel fans is that the Gimbels Passageway is coming back, at least on paper. Officials say the original tunnel is too narrow and decayed to reopen as is, so the plan is a wider passage built into the foundation of a new office tower. That tower is Vornado's, on the old Hotel Pennsylvania site across Seventh Avenue from the station. The rendering shows a corridor lined with coffee shops and high-end stores, something like the concourse under Rockefeller Center. The catch is that Vornado has demolished the hotel but hasn't built the tower, and nobody has put an opening date on the passage.

What's fascinating is how much the route has moved around over the years. Vornado's 2010 planning map ran the new connection under 33rd Street, basically Gimbels rebuilt. A later Penn District map from around 2020 drew something completely different: a corridor running east from Penn 2, under Seventh Avenue, straight through the 11 Penn Plaza block, and out to Sixth Avenue near the PATH. It even had Long Island Rail Road, Amtrak and NJ Transit icons at the Sixth Avenue end, which suggests a true extension of the station and not just a walkway. The state's 2021 plan hedged with two options, one along West 32nd Street and one under 33rd, subject to more study of engineering and financial feasibility. Now, in 2026, the conversation is back on 33rd Street.

For anyone who lives or works around here, that's worth watching. A climate-controlled link from Penn Station to Herald Square and the PATH would be a real upgrade for every office building, hotel and apartment along the way. Just don't plan your commute around it yet.

Until Then: Your Neighborhood Agent's Weatherproof Route

Here's what I tell clients, friends and anyone who asks. When it's pouring, snowing, freezing or just brutally hot, walk up Seventh Avenue to Macy's. The store takes up the whole block between Seventh Avenue and Broadway, from 34th to 35th Street. Go in on the Seventh Avenue side, cut straight through the store, and come out on Broadway. You'll be right at the Herald Square subway entrances, and you'll have spent most of the trip indoors. The only catch is store hours, so it won't help on an early morning commute.

Penn Station spent decades as the place New Yorkers just put up with. That's finally changing, one concourse at a time. The old tunnels may be gone, but the next generation is already being drawn up, and I'll be keeping an eye on every step. Until then, you know where to find me: cutting through Macy's with a dry umbrella.


Popular Posts:

Your Rent Freeze Just Kicked In. Are You Actually Covered?

A Comprehensive Guide to Watch Shopping in New York City

The Trump Name in New York Real Estate: Which Buildings Still Have It and Which Have Dropped It