The 6 Best Consignment Stores in Manhattan (2025 Edition): Where Style Meets Sustainability

Whether you're a fashion lover hunting for hidden designer gems or just looking to refresh your wardrobe without breaking the bank, Manhattan's consignment scene offers a treasure trove of high-end finds. In 2025, the borough is bursting with beautifully curated boutiques that blend luxury, sustainability, and serious style cred. From East Village vintage dens to Upper East Side staples for Chanel and Hermès, these six standout consignment shops have earned glowing reviews and recent media buzz alike. Here’s your guide to the very best, complete with up-to-date addresses, website links, and real customer testimonials.

1. Stock Vintage — East Village

Address: 143 E 13th St, Manhattan, NY
Cited as NYC.com’s #1 consignment & vintage shop for 2025, this East Village menswear specialist is celebrated for its exquisite curated selection spanning decades of vintage styles.
Reviews:

“The best vintage curator in NYC in my opinion. Melissa's inventory reaches far & wide, her store's range of decades through menswear is unmatched.” (Yelp) (Yelp)
“Stock Vintage is a necessity for anyone seeking vintage clothing in NYC! Their collection of 1920s‑1960s menswear is the best in the city.” (Yelp)

2. Tokio 7 — East Village

Address: 83 E 7th St, Manhattan, NY
Ranked #2 on NYC.com’s 2025 list, Tokio 7 specializes in high-end designer vintage and archive pieces—think rare Japanese labels plus big names like Prada and Bottega Veneta (TOKIO7).
Reviews:

“Pretty cool place to check out, overrepresented by some Japanese labels that are usually hard to find elsewhere, and stocked full of stuff.” (Yelp)
“The store is very tidy, orderly and the garments are displayed with ease of viewing. Over the last couple visits however prices seem to have snuck up a bit.” (Tripadvisor)

3. Ina (SoHo location) — SoHo

Address: 101 Thompson St, Manhattan, NY
Ina is a well‑known upscale consignment mini‑chain, offering current-season designer items—often 30–50% below retail—from labels like McQueen, Lang, Gucci, Hermès and more.
 

Reviews:

“We always have a great shopping experience at INA! Gina is fantastic, and the inventory is refreshed often. Highly recommend!!” (Yelp)

4. Michael’s, The Consignment Shop for Women — Upper East Side

Address: Upper East Side, Manhattan (Madison Ave area)
Founded in 1954, Michael’s is iconic for authenticated first-tier designer resale—Dior, Prada, J. P. Gaultier—often offered at 70–90% off retail. It’s featured in Yelp’s top consignment lists too. (Michaels Luxury Consignment)
 

Reviews:

“As a consignor, Michael's has priced my items fairly, and always been punctual mailing checks every month. They are selective about what they will accept, but you are assured pieces that are almost like new when you shop.” (Yelp)
“Really nice high end brands at decent prices. I recently made a shoe purchase online. The price was great, the shoes were in top notch condition.” (Tripadvisor)

5. Consignment on 72nd (now Tanya Luxury Fashion Boutique) — Upper West Side

Address: 133 W 72nd St, Manhattan, NY
Launched in early 2024 and rebranded late 2024, this boutique brings luxury designer and contemporary consignment to the UWS, with curated pieces from Celine, Chanel, Gucci, Dior, Loro Piana, Brunello Cucinelli and more.

6. A Second Chance Resale — SoHo & Upper East Side

Addresses: 100 Lexington Ave 2nd Floor (Upper East Side) & 115 Prince St (SoHo)
Family‑owned luxury resale in operation for 30+ years, stocking designer handbags, clothing and accessories—Chanel, Hermès, Louis Vuitton—in pristine, authenticated condition (asecondchanceresale.com).
Reviews:

“The establishment is amazing and Maria the owner is fantabulous. She is gracious, professional, super friendly and makes for great conversation.” (Yelp)
“What a hidden gem in the UES! I was not expecting to buy anything but I found 2 items that I was obsessed with. I got a reversible bomber jacket and a long black leather coat.” (MapQuest)